Voice in art
For a long time, when I thought about the idea of “voice,” I thought only about words. Voice was something I heard on the page, in the rhythm of a writer’s sentences and the particular way they noticed the world, and it was the thing that let me recognize a writer within a paragraph, and know what their worldview was.
Over the past several years, as I’ve spent my time with illustrators and author-illustrators, I’ve found myself looking for illustrative voice just as closely. I’ve come to see how the artistic voice in a book matters every bit as much as the textual voice.
I call it illustrative voice, and I use that phrase on purpose, because it works almost exactly the way a writer’s voice does. It lives in how you build a character’s face, where you put the weight in a composition, how you use color to set a mood, and what you choose to exaggerate and what you leave subdued. An editor or art director opening your portfolio should be able to feel that voice within the first few images, the same way they can hear a writer’s voice on the first page of a manuscript, and your portfolio is where you have the opportunity to get your voice across.
Your unique style
Thinking of portfolios as a whole: when everything you can do goes into one portfolio, though, what an editor/art director sees is an artist who hasn’t decided, or isn’t clear, on who they are yet, and that makes it hard for them to imagine your work on a specific book that they have in their hand at the moment.
You can have more than one style, and plenty of working illustrators do. What matters is that those styles are clearly differentiated and that there aren’t too many of them. If you have two very different ways of working, it’s best to keep two separate portfolios, or separate them so distinctly within one site that nobody has to wonder which version of you they’re looking at.
If you have many, it’s time to sit with your work and figure out which of those are your voice and which were experiments that taught you something on the way there. Your voice will keep evolving, as it should, and you’ll try new paths over the course of a career, and that growth is part of your work.
A portfolio is a living document of who you are right now, and what you’re ready to be hired for, and it should show focus.
Part of that focus is knowing who you’re illustrating for.
A board book, a picture book, a chapter book, a young graphic novel, and a middle grade graphic novel each ask different things of an illustrator, and an editor or art director looking for one of them is scanning your work for signs that you understand their reader.
I taught elementary school before I became an agent, and I still think about the kids who will hold these books, how a three-year-old reads a picture differently than an eight-year-old does, how much a newly independent reader leans on the art to carry them through a page of text, and how a ten-year-old wants characters who look and feel close to their own age.
Portfolio through lines
All of this comes back to the through line. When I look at a portfolio that works, I can trace something running through every piece: a consistency of voice and intent that tells me this artist knows what they’re doing and who they’re doing it for. The subjects can and should vary, since you want to show range in characters, settings, emotions, and moments, but the person making those images should be recognizable in every one of them.
If you want to put this into practice, here are some exercises I’d give any illustrator working on a portfolio.
Write down your through line. Lay your whole portfolio out, on a table or a wall or a single screen, and try to describe what connects these pieces in one or two sentences. If you can’t answer that in a sentence or two, an editor or art director won’t be able to either, and that tells you where to start.
Ask someone else to describe your work. Show your portfolio to a friend who isn’t an illustrator, and ask them to tell you, in a few words, what kind of artist made it. Then compare their words with the sentence you wrote in the first exercise, and if the two descriptions sound like different people, your portfolio is telling a different story than the one you think you’re telling.
Sort by style. Group every piece into sections by how it was made and how it looks. If you have one, wonderful. If you have two that are clearly distinct, decide whether they belong in two separate portfolios or two clearly marked sections. If you have three or more, choose the one that feels most like you and that you’d be happiest drawing for an entire book, and let the others be on the back burner for now.
Name your reader. For each piece, write down the age of the child you imagine holding the book it belongs in, and then look at the spread of those ages. If your work covers everything from board books to middle grade, decide which range you most want to be hired for and make sure the bulk of your portfolio speaks to that reader.
Draw the same character three times. Take one character and show them in three different scenes with three different emotions. Editors and art directors want to know you can keep a character consistent across a whole book, and this will show you, and them, whether your voice holds steady from page to page.
Put your work next to the books you want to make. Pull up the covers and interiors of a few recent books in the age range you’re aiming for, the ones you would love to have illustrated, and place your pieces beside them. Ask yourself whether your work could sit on the same shelf, while still sounding entirely like you.
Cut three pieces. Go through your portfolio and remove the three pieces that feel least connected to the rest—even if one of them is a favorite. Then look at what’s left and notice how much clearer your voice becomes when it isn’t competing with work that’s pulling in another direction.
What you’re working toward is a portfolio where someone can look at your work and know right away who you are as an artist and which books you’re meant to make, because that distinctness is what lets an editor or art director picture your art in a finished book, on a shelf and in the hands of young readers.
I hope this helps in some way!
And further, I hope everyone in the U.S. has a wonderful Thanksgiving week and holiday. I will be busy baking seven or so pies, along with my Aunt’s famous stuffing, which is one of the one true family secret recipes I have.
What pie is your favorite? I want to know! And I’m always excited for new recipes—even if I have too many for any single day, or even a single season.
Happy Holidays!