Finding the keys

Storytime

Thrice over the past three months, I’ve misplaced my car keys. I can keep count because typically, I always know where my keys are (along with every other item I own). My keys live in a specific pocket of my bag, and in a specific tray by my front door.

But then, this summer, I locked my keys in the car, not realizing until I needed to drive my littlest to camp—to the Bronx from Brooklyn, no less. I really needed the car. The second time, six weeks later, I was unpacking the first pumpkin haul and dropped the keys in the backseat before locking up. When I returned later, my first worried thought was that I had to move the car for the street sweeper very soon.

This past week was the third occurrence of the sort.

I was almost ready to leave the city—I was driving out to Connecticut, and I had somewhere I needed to be at a certain time. Walking through the neighborhood, I pulled my keys set out of the only compartment in my bag where they ever are found, but then I decided to take a quick detour to one of my favorite coffee shops to get a cup of tea to go. I walked across the street, turned around, and noticed the light was hitting the leaves in the park with a certain autumnal perfection, so I stuffed the keys into my pants pocket, then took out my phone to take a photo. Satisfied with the picture, I walked into the coffee shop, ordered my tea, and chatted with the baristas before heading out.

My car was only a block and a half away, and as I walked, I glanced into the storefronts and gazed up at the golden foliage on the trees.

All of these details are seared into my brain, because of what happened next. I set my tea on the car hood, reached for my keys in my jeans, and discovered they weren’t there. I figured I put them back into their special spot in my bag, and when I found that empty, my heart rate began to pick up slightly.

A few minutes later, after digging through my belongings, when I accepted the fact that my keys were gone, I began to get frazzled. I was on a schedule, and I needed to leave.

What followed was a ninety-minute search for a set of keys I never, ever lose, all centered around a single radius of less than two blocks. I went back into the coffee shop two times, and the baristas, who know me, were concerned enough to do a sweep of the place. I asked every shopkeeper on the route if anyone had turned in a set of sidewalk keys. I scoured every surface, each window ledge, all the parking meters and metal boxes attached to light posts to see if someone had set the keys there. Kind strangers joined the hunt for a moment or two. I rummaged through planters in case they’d been picked up and dropped there, and I even peered into garbage cans, just to be thorough.

I was circling, muttering to myself, retracing my steps, down to repeating the action of removing my phone from my bag to see if the muscle movement would trigger a memory of exactly where the keys might have dropped.

By the time I’d been at this for over an hour, I was in a panic.

After the first two car key incidents, I now keep a lock-out key in my bag. But I was hesitant to use it, mostly because I wasn’t sure it would actually start the car and let me drive it, and I wanted to avoid finding out for as long as possible. Besides, I knew my keys had to be somewhere. It was impossible for them not to be.

I was cold without my jacket, anxious about where I was supposed to be, and trying to make jokes to myself for levity. “I guess Brooklyn really doesn’t want me to say goodbye, hahaha. Ha.”

I walked down the same fifty feet I’d been down a dozen times already, when my eyes caught something on the ledge.

I screamed out loud and ran over as if I’d stumbled upon my missing child. The keys were there, on a black-painted ledge, sitting so calmly I might have called them bored. Facing out was my key chain, reading “Beware of the Ghosts.”

The likely explanation is that the keys somehow fell out of my pocket—how, I still can't figure out—somebody scooped them up and set them on the nearest window ledge, and because the black blended into the black, I happened to miss this one spot.

The theory I think is more fun to believe, especially now that October is upon us, is that there’s a ghost who’s been having a wonderful time messing with me—maybe for months now. It would certainly explain a handful of other experiences I’ve had recently! Plus, my key chain literally warns me to beware them.

The photo I took! Was it worth it? Kinda.

Now that my nervous system has reset, I’m fine with replaying this story, and it’s why I wanted to write it out.

Anything can be a symbol if you make it one

The short version of this event is: I lost my keys on the sidewalk and spent a long time looking for them. But the vivid story is an entire encounter, and it’s one I’ve been thinking about—not only because I like to wonder if ghosts were a part of it, and not only because it makes me smile to think that Brooklyn itself didn’t want to see me go—but also because of the layers. The through line of it.

I’m not usually one for a heavy-handed metaphor—not in stories for kids, not in stories for myself. But I’m also not usually one for misplacing my keys three times over so few fortnights. There’s an element to this that I’m going to spell out, because sometimes the most on-the-nose metaphors are the ones that can give us new perspective in our daily lives.

The keys were in plain sight, but it took a long, frantic, and increasingly undignified search to find them. This can be true for our creative work, too. The keys should have been easy to find. I think many of us feel the same when we’re staring down a deadline, an editorial letter, art notes, or feedback from critique partners. Or maybe when there’s a barrier that should be straightforward to break through—obvious flatness in a piece of art or a clearly clunky ending to a story. What is the key to making this piece work? What’s the key to making it shine?

It could be broader, like finding the key to unlock a productive work schedule after a scattered summer, or a more fulfilling creative rhythm that will bring joy to the dark, colder days ahead. It can be hard to find that key in the middle of stagnation or frustration, or on a busy sidewalk while passersby stare as you crouch to look under a mailbox while in near-tears.

I’d love to share a pivotal beat of wisdom from this encounter that led me to my inevitable triumph—something like, “I took a deep breath, looked around with new eyes, and once I changed how I saw things, I found what was sitting directly in front of me!”

A a craft tip: characters should never just “take a deep breath, then realize…” as the turning point of their narrative arc. It's not an interesting choice on the page, or in life.

I don’t know why I didn’t see my keys the first time, or the second, or third. I was looking in every direction, and most likely, my gaze did fall on them at one point early on, and I didn’t register them. I don’t know why I finally noticed them when I did. But I’m glad I didn’t stop looking.

Previous
Previous

Do you have a question? Ask the spirits!

Next
Next

Fall reading (and a book club!)